View Full Version : CDC calls on all states to test some prisoners for Hepatitis C


danielle
01-23-2003, 09:33 PM
By Jennifer Lin and Mark Fazlollah
Knight Ridder Newspapers
(KRT)
PHILADELPHIA - With a million inmates infected by hepatitis C leaving jails each year, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Thursday called on states to test all prisoners with a history of intravenous drug abuse - a common way the virus is spread.

It also set guidelines for educating and treating prisoners with the potentially lethal disease, now an epidemic behind bars.

But the federal agency stopped short of pressuring states to test entire prison populations - a subject of intense debate among corrections officials because of the cost.

If more inmates are screened for the blood-borne virus, more are likely to qualify for medicines. The year-long treatment can effectively cure half the cases but costs as much as $25,000.

New Jersey estimates that if it tests 25 percent of its inmates, it will have to spend about $4.5 million on hepatitis C therapy. But if it tests 75 percent of its population, the cost will jump to $8 million.

In making its recommendation, the CDC said targeted testing of inmates would catch most cases of hepatitis C. But it advised states to make sure that approach was working with periodic reviews.

Pennsylvania currently tests all prisoners, not just those at high risk. It says 20 percent are infected and hundreds are being treated.

In New Jersey, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported last summer, prisons were failing to monitor the epidemic and were treating only one inmate. The state has since launched a plan to expand care.

New Jersey was also releasing prisoners without telling them that they had tested positive for the virus - a problem it says has been corrected.

Of the nation's one million infected prisoners released each year, it is unknown how many have been told of their hepatitis C, the CDC said Thursday. If inmates aren't informed, they can unwittingly spread the disease.

In its announcement Thursday, published in its Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, the CDC spelled out inmate care after prisons diagnose hepatitis C. Those showing signs of liver disease should be assessed by hepatitis specialists to determine whether they need the latest dual-drug therapy. Those who qualify should get the medicines.

Although the CDC cannot mandate policy for prisons, its recommendations will influence how states wrestle with the explosion of hepatitis C cases in corrections. The CDC says various states have reported that 16 percent to 41 percent of prisoners are infected.

Cindy Weinbaum, a CDC hepatitis specialist who prepared the recommendations, said some prison officials argue that money is not available for treatment. But federal law requires states to treat sick inmates.

"Denying treatment that would be a standard of treatment on the outside would not be acceptable," she said.

The CDC said 39 percent of the 3 million Americans with chronic hepatitis C infection will pass through prisons or jails each year, which puts the institutions on the frontlines for screening, counseling and treating the disease.

Medical advances make it harder for prison officials to ignore the hepatitis C problem.

"Two or three years ago, therapies were not very effective," said Joseph Paris, medical director for the Georgia corrections department. "But there's less and less justification for not treating as therapies are becoming more effective."

With many states now grappling with the problem, the CDC will host a conference in San Antonio next week to address management of the disease in corrections.

The virus, which attacks the liver, must pass directly into a person's blood. Injection drug users run the highest risk of infection, which is why prisons are overrun with cases. The CDC said 83 percent of state prisoners and 73 percent of federal prisoners reported past drug abuse.

Jeffrey Beard, Pennsylvania's corrections secretary, said he believed the state's program of universal testing was better than the CDC's recommendation of screening only those at high risk.

"If you go the other way, you'll miss a substantial group," Beard said Thursday.

tebkrg
01-24-2003, 04:25 AM
COST?

What I don't understand is where the heads are of some of the government and prison officials. The COST is there whether in prison or out! What is the COST going to be for the prisons when this spirals out of control behind the walls? It is already out of hand and it can only get worse untreated. We must and they must know who is infected now and treat this! Most of these men and women that are infected are getting out one day. If treatment does not start NOW while they are inside the COST will just be transfered to the free world when they get out and I hesitate to say that the COST will be higher then. We will be facing many Prisoners whose illness will be too far along to effectively treat and the cost of health care of someone critically ill with HEP C will be higher than to treat it and possibly cure it while inside. The we also have the fear of those that are not tested and are walking around without symptoms and they get out and possibly infect their loved ones innocently. The COST is not an issue here. In fact the COST is the issue but in the sense of what the COST will be if Prisoners are not tested and treated. What will the long term COST be?

Libra3
01-24-2003, 07:22 AM
Yeah well, unfortunately they really don't give a rat's *#@ about it. My friend's father is in USMCFP with my man and he has been turned down twice for HCV treatment and his condition seems to be worsening. She has been told that her father will probably be turned down again. He has been waiting 18 months....what does it take? If they dont want to take care of these people then they should release them to their loved ones who do want to.

Carol

KConnor56
01-29-2003, 10:50 AM
The Philadelphia Inquirer
Posted on Fri, Jan. 24, 2003
CDC: Test all inmates at risk for hepatitis C
A history of intravenous drug abuse should trigger tests, the agency said.
Pa. and N.J. have programs.
By Jennifer Lin and Mark Fazlollah
Inquirer Staff Writers
With a million inmates infected by hepatitis C leaving jails each year, the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention yesterday called on states to
test all prisoners with a history of intravenous drug abuse - a common way
the virus is spread.
It also set guidelines for educating and treating prisoners with the
potentially lethal disease, now an epidemic behind bars affecting 16
percent to 41 percent of prisoners, depending on the state.
The recommendations come as states, including Pennsylvania and New Jersey,
have grappled with the cost of treating hepatitis C behind bars versus the
ethical, legal and public-health implications of not treating.
The federal agency stopped short of pressuring states to test entire prison
populations - a subject of intense debate among corrections officials
because of the cost.
If more inmates are screened for the blood-borne virus, more are likely to
qualify for medicines. The yearlong treatment can effectively cure half the
cases but costs as much as $25,000.
New Jersey estimates that if it tests a fourth of its inmates, it will have
to spend about $4.5 million on hepatitis C therapy. If it tests 75 percent
of its population, the cost will jump to $8 million.
Pennsylvania has treated or is preparing to treat more than 1,000 inmates
at a cost of about $6 million
In making its recommendation, the CDC said targeted testing of inmates
would catch most cases of hepatitis C. But it advised states to make sure,
with periodic reviews, that approach was working.
In New Jersey, The Inquirer reported last summer, prisons were failing to
monitor the epidemic and were treating only one inmate while others were
falling sick and dying. The state has since launched a plan to expand care.
New Jersey was also releasing prisoners without telling them that they had
tested positive for the virus - a problem it says has been corrected.
Of the nation's one million infected prisoners released each year, it is
unknown how many have been told of their hepatitis C, the CDC said
yesterday. If inmates aren't informed, they can unwittingly spread the disease.
In its announcement, published in its Morbidity and Mortality Weekly
Report, the CDC spelled out the care prisons should give inmates with
hepatitis C. Those showing signs of liver disease should be assessed by
hepatitis specialists to determine whether they need the latest dual-drug
therapy. Those who qualify should then get the medicines.
Although the CDC cannot mandate policy for prisons, its recommendations
will influence how states wrestle with the explosion of hepatitis C cases
in corrections facilities.
Cindy Weinbaum, a CDC hepatitis specialist who prepared the
recommendations, said some prison officials argue that money is not
available for treatment. Federal law requires states to treat sick inmates.
"Denying treatment that would be a standard of treatment on the outside
would not be acceptable," she said.
The CDC said 39 percent of the three million Americans with chronic
hepatitis C infection will pass through prisons or jails each year, which
puts the institutions on the front lines for screening, counseling and
treating the disease.
Medical advances make it harder for prison officials to ignore the
hepatitis C problem.
"Two or three years ago, therapies were not very effective," said Joseph
Paris, medical director for the Georgia corrections department. "But
there's less and less justification for not treating, as therapies are
becoming more effective."
Next week, the CDC will host a conference in San Antonio, Texas, to address
management of the disease in corrections facilities.
The virus, which attacks the liver, must pass directly into a person's
blood. Injection drug users run the highest risk of infection, which is why
prisons are overrun with cases. The CDC said 83 percent of state prisoners
and 73 percent of federal prisoners reported past drug abuse.
Jeffrey Beard, Pennsylvania's corrections secretary, said he believed the
state's program of universal testing was better than the CDC's
recommendation of screening only those at high risk.
"If you go the other way, you'll miss a substantial group," Beard said
yesterday.
Of Pennsylvania's 38,000 inmates, 7,538 have tested positive for hepatitis C.
New Jersey's prison doctors estimate that 25 percent of the state's 26,000
inmates would test positive for hepatitis C if all were screened. However,
with limited screening, the state knows of only 1,407 cases - 5 percent of
the inmates.

Contact Inquirer reporter Mark Fazlollah at 215-854-5831 or
mfazlollah@phillynews.com. To see previous Inquirer articles on hepatitis C
on line: go.philly.com/hepatitis.
--

IRIST
01-29-2003, 11:31 AM
YES YOU ALL ARE RIGHT, THE GOVERMENT DOES NOT CARE ABOUT ANY INMATE, ALL THEY WORRY ABOUT IS THE MONEY THEY GET FROM THEM BEING LOCKED UP. LOOKS LIKE THEY WOULD WANT TO HELP THESE INMATES KEEP THIS HEP. C, FROM NOT SPREADING TO THE FREE WORLD AND ESPECIALLY IN THEIR PRISONS, THEY THEMSELF MIGHT HAVE AN ACCIDENT AND BECOME INFECTED WITH IT ALSO, YES IT IS GOING TO COST THE GOVERMENT ONE WAY OR THE OTHER, IN PRISON OR WHEN THEY COME INTO THE FREE WORLD, IT IS A SHAME THAT THEY FEEL LIKE IF YOU DID A CRIME AND GO TO PRISON, WHY SHOULD WE TAKE CARE OF YOU, BUT THEY ARE SUSPOSE TO, THEY ARE THE WARDS OF THE STATE NOW. BUT WILL THESE THINGS EVER CHANGE FOR A BETTER OUTLOOK ON OUR PRISONS? LETS ALL HOPE AND PRAY FOR BETTER THINGS TO COME AND FOR ALL INMATES TO BE TREATED LIKE THEY ARE STILL HUMAN BEINGS AND CHILDREN OF GOD, WHICH WE ALL ARE. SO GOD BLESS US ALL AND HAVE MERCY ON US ALL.

Menally-Ill
01-29-2003, 05:38 PM
You might be surprised to learn that the reason Pennsylvania seems so "humane" about this testing, is because about 4 years back they decided to Hep C test the entire fire department in Philadelphia. Lo and behold, they discovered about 40 % of their firefighters ARE Hep C + (positive)! Needless to say there were huge lawsuits, which the firefighters WON, and now Penn. takes the Hep c epidemic seriously!

All My Love,
Menolly

BlockinNC
03-08-2004, 05:32 PM
You wrote an excellent piece on the different types of hepititis however, I don't remeber where I saw it, and I cannot locate it again. would you know where I could fine it

francis
04-22-2004, 03:15 AM
tekbrg, i don't understand your argument that it willl cost the government more money once the inmate is out...
is this due to the government having to be responsible for the inmate as a convicted felon? since, inmates are government property..i don't know the specifics of how this works..

treatment now is approximately $20,000, the protocol is usualy for a year to 18 months on genotype 1b, and less on the 2's i believe..but, don't quote me on which of the 2's..

unless, one is elegible for gov't assisstance=poor, and not all states help the same, one will have to pay for their own treatment...and, if one does not have insurance, which many don't this can be a tragedy, and very expensive...for insurance companies will not cover individuals with pre-existing conditions at a reasonable price, and some won't at all..

here in los angeles, california, thus far if you are poor you can receive gov't care for hep c through the county, right now it is a three month waiting list to be seen, i am not sure yet, how soon they begin treatment..

the best bet is to work for a company that has group insurance, then people with for example a diagnosis hiv/aids or hep c will be covered...

to not treat ill prisoners is inhumane. period.

this lack of treatment, in particular of a progressive and fatal illness is a serious testament to the state of our country...it is heart breaking, and completly a sin!!

the u.s. is the wealthiest country in the world, lack of funds is never the problem...simply look at our daily growing military budget, suddenly the argument that there is not enough money sounds ridiculous...suddenly the u.s. government is capable of find billions of dollars to fund our war, money that couldn't be found before...

just some thoughts....