View Full Version : Why Rachel Ward is celebrating the release of a teenage sex offender


Nemesis
05-03-2004, 11:33 PM
Sydney Morning Herald (http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/05/03/1083436545327.html?from=top5#)
By Natasha Wallace
May 4, 2004

A teenage boy who sexually assaulted a nine-year-old girl will be freed early - and his mentor, actress Rachel Ward, says it's a good thing.

Ward was delighted by yesterday's unanimous decision by the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal to release the boy who, aged 13, attacked the girl on the way home from school, pinning her to the ground and forcing himself upon her. The girl's mother, who had gone looking for her after she had not returned home by 3.30pm on March 4, 2002, discovered the boy on top of her daughter after she followed her screams to a nearby field.

It was an "extreme case", but the boy, who is now 16, would be better off out of the Reiby Juvenile Detention Centre, where his counselling was "minimal" and "inadequate", Ward said.

She had been visiting him, with her partner Bryan Brown, every fortnight through a mentoring program called Big hArt, which involves about 3000 disadvantaged children. "No one is suggesting what he did is right but there is a reason why a 13-year-old boy expresses himself in such a way," she said.

She said he desperately needed a positive male role model, and would benefit from mentoring programs.

She said his 22-year-old sister, who will now care for him alone, was a "very formidable and together girl" but would also need support.

He is not permitted to be in the company of children under 12 alone and is required to attend weekly counselling sessions until December 2006.

He was sentenced on December 5, 2003 to three years detention, with a non-parole period of one year, after he pleaded guilty to sexual intercourse with a person under the age of 10. The offence carries a maximum penalty of 25 years.

In his judgement handed down yesterday, Justice David Kirby said the boy had a deprived childhood. He had never met his Aboriginal father, and his mother, who suffered from depression, put him into the care of a 50-year-old family friend when he was 11. The family friend sexually abused him.

Seven months before he attacked the girl, he had tried to hang himself.

A juvenile justice counsellor, Jeannette Liva, said during his sentencing hearing last year that he should not be given a custodial sentence because he would get "very limited" therapy.

"The psychologists that work in the detention centre have an incredibly high workload, and they're usually . . . fire-fighting," Ms Liva said.

In 2002, 90 boys and one girl were convicted of sexual assault, according to the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics.

Dale Tolliday, of the New Street Adolescent Service run by NSW Health, said that such offenders should never be detained because there is "no evidence to show that that's going to solve the problem".

Nigel Spence, chief executive officer of the Association of Children's Welfare Agencies, said that help for young sex offenders was in "short supply".

The NSW Department of Juvenile Justice would not comment on the issue.

jude
05-06-2004, 04:54 AM
Trying, as I am, to understand all the why' and where for's of this case, WHY is there just NO mention of any help for the little girl of 9 that this happened to? She will probably be marked by it for the rest of her life.
Jude

Rostonhall
05-09-2004, 06:44 AM
Much as I sympathize with the girl I'm sure she's had all the counselling possible in this matter and that her life will be quite normal after this. The boy, on the other hand, seems to need a whole lot more help and detention of any sort is not the answer. To try to hang himself at such a young age shows just how disturbed his poor little mind must be. And please don't start screaming at me that I don't know what I'm talking about. I was the victim of sexual abuse from the age of 2 until around 7 or 8 years of age when the guy involved went into the Air Force during the days of National Service. And I also have first hand experience from the boy's point of view, where a very young 'rapist', who was abused himself as child, served time in adult prison, even though a minor, has turned into the most wonderful, caring person you could ever want to meet.

I'm so glad someone like Rachel Ward is helping and I can think of no better mentor, if he should agree, than Bryan Brown, an actor I've admired for many years.

Rose

jude
05-09-2004, 09:07 AM
I am not saying that Rachel Ward should not help him. I think it is wonderful that someone like her has come forward TO help him. Obviously he is in dire need of help. All I am saying is that there is NO mention of the 9 year old receiving any support. Maybe she got counselling, maybe she didn't. Maybe her life will be normal, but there is always pain and memories for her. I am just saying that as part of this article it wouldn't have hurt to have told us what support she was receiving. As people, you and me, involved with men in prison, regardless of their innocence ,I always try to not take sides because while I try to understand why someone committed an offence,I try also to be aware of the victims. People always assume that because a man is locked up in prison that he just has to be guilty and this isn't always the case, but I still try to see both sides.I also was a victim of child abuse and there was no counselling, but being angry only drains you and achieves nothing I have found.

Rostonhall
05-09-2004, 11:08 AM
I had no couselling whatsoever and I'm neither bitter nor angry and I've learned not to look too deeply into why someone does something. There is always something to contradict whatever I may think was the cause of someone breaking the law. And, as I used to work for the Probation Service, I've got to know all sorts of people who've done every imaginable crime and I've yet to find a common denominator.

Rose

softheart
05-09-2004, 11:22 AM
Jude I would venture to say the reason the article did not mention about the girl was because it was an article about what happened with the boy. I am sure this is not the first article about the case.

The problem I see here is that no where does it say the boy will be ordered for counseling. Having a Male role model and being part of a mentoring program is not going to get to the root of why at such a young age he is acting out like this.

I agree that Detention is not the place, but I do not believe he should be out and about without help.

Rose you are lucky that you were able to get passed what happened, many victims do live with it for the rest of their lives and are not able to get passed it without counseling.

Even though he was 13 at the time, I am a Psychologist and I work with Kids at Risk such as this young man and there is a problem, there is a reason he is acting out like this and to ignore it won't make it go away and punishing won't help either.

softie

Rostonhall
05-09-2004, 11:58 AM
I obviously read the article differently to you, softie, because to me it's saying 'we can't help him within the detention system so let him out and he'll get what he needs.' This would be over and above the mentor showing him, by example, that there's a better life for him than the one he's been forced to lead.

Yes, I know I've been very lucky in that I didn't need counselling at all. The fact is, nobody knew about my abuse and, when I finally admitted to it less than 10 years ago, my doctor told me that, to send me to therapy then, would do more harm than good. I totally agree with that and I'm thankful I have the personality, strength and intelligence to have been able to survive. I know a lot of people can't but I've been able to do it on my own, without any help.

Rose

Kyla
05-10-2004, 03:46 AM
They have put boundaries on the boy, he cant use the internet, in case he gets photos of young girls, he cant travel on public transport (well they are trying to pass that on all SO offenders), so his life is going to be far from normal.

It is more in the media, as 2 well known celebraties, Rachel Ward and Bryan Brown, have had alot to do with the story. What about the other young offenders?

As for the girl, I hope that she has had the councelling she needs and heals. This young boy has now been registered as a SO, so at the young age of 13, has marked his life all through adulthood.

Rostonhall
05-10-2004, 07:45 AM
I know they meant well when all the SO rules were brought in, and they are meant to safeguard people but, and there's a big but, there should be some way a young child can be taken off the register after a number of abuse free years. This knee jerk reaction was the result of witch hunts being carried out by victims and their families, and I think it's now gone too far and is causing too much heartache for the those associated with, and the families of, SOs.

I truly hope this young boy can now look forward to some sort of normality and that others will be taken care of, too.

Rose

Kyla
05-10-2004, 04:39 PM
Rose
Some shocking things are happening in the Australian judicial system right now, and that is one of them, leaving young SO on a register, and making them public, among other things. I am going to try and get some information up today about all the changes they have been talking about on the news. And its election time here to :(

Rostonhall
05-11-2004, 03:52 AM
I'll look forward to reading anythng you find, Kyla. Doesn't this sort of thing always happen around election time when whoever has performed so badly they start introducing things they think will bring in the votes and, unfortunately, it usually works because people don't think of the consequences.

Rose

strangeanimal
05-11-2004, 05:19 AM
I feel for the boy....having to go through the abuse as a young boy and having all those feelings roaming around inside...he reminds me of my man. He went through tremdous abuse..sexual and physical and he grew up to be a molester. I wish that somehow...his feelings get dealt with soon. Early intervention is the key and showing him that there is another way to be are great. I also like the idea Rachel Ward is helping him....there is such a stigma against sexual offenders. Alot of people just want them to disappear. For her to take a stand and in the public eye, it's a tremendous thing to do. Hopeful change the way we look at offenders...they are hurt little children. No matter how old they are.

Kyla
05-11-2004, 04:49 PM
Strangeanimal
I totally agree with you there. At such a young age, there is a HUGE successful chance that this young boy can be rehabilitated. Like last night, on the news, this 15 year old girl was taking her father to court for slapping her across the face.
Then you hear about a 13 year old boy, we dont know anything about his upbringing, but something would of triggered inside his head to have done this.
Dont get me wrong, it was horrible for what happened to the victim, the young 9 year old, but he is only 4 years older than her, and a minor as well. Condemning him for the rest of his life isnt going to help his circumstances.
I agree that it is good that there has been intervention, and I can only pray that there is more internvention to young offenders.
Here in Queensland they are allowed to bring up juvenille history. It is so sad, to hear in a courtroom, a DA (DPP here) saying, well at the age of 13, they commited this criminal offence (and now they are adults) and put it down as a prior felony, when if you think about it, someone could of stepped in and helped before they were standing in front of a judge, as an adult, getting re-tried for there past, and the ultimate sentence the courts can hand down here cause its considered a "prior"
anyway ,thats my soap box for the day.