TNC
02-12-2005, 09:10 AM
A House panel agreed Friday to consider two bills that would allow some convicted felons to go free sooner to relieve pressures on a state prison system that has swelled beyond capacity.
But both proposals may be nonstarters; Gov. Dirk Kempthorne in January created a special commission to examine the state's criminal sentences. And Senate Judiciary Chairman Denton Darrington has vowed to block any measure that would result in lighter sentences for the state's prison population.
Still, House Judiciary Committee members say the prison crisis at least makes the proposals worth examining now, rather than waiting for Kempthorne's commission to move.
The first proposal is from Boise Republican Rep. Steve Smylie, whose plan would allow inmates who have completed education, drug abuse and other required treatments to shave four months off their sentences.
That, Smylie said, would potentially save the state as much as $4 million a year.
Another proposal, from Kuna Republican Rep. Bill Sali, would allow prisoners who have committed nonviolent crimes to automatically be paroled as long as certain conditions are met.
Smylie said his proposal is modeled after a similar plan used in Nebraska, where the prisons have fewer inmates than Idaho's more than 6,300, even though Nebraska has half a million more people than Idaho.
Republican Rep. Jim Clark of Hayden Lake objected to considering Smylie's proposal, saying the governor's commission was going to do its own examination of the issue.
But Pocatello Democratic Rep. Donna Boe pushed for legislative review right away.
"It seems to me that were we to pass this through the Legislature, it would get more attention" from the governor's commission, Boe said.
Boe succeeded in backing the introduction of Smylie's bill, complete with her own changes, giving the Parole Commission veto authority over a reduced sentence.
Sali's proposal would restrict the Parole Commission's ability to block the parole of nonviolent offenders unless the panel can demonstrate that the release of the prisoner would be a threat to society.
If the inmate has no disciplinary issues, has finished prison treatment and other required programs, he can be let go after finishing the minimum, or fixed, portion of the prison sentence. The bill would also create a six-month mandatory parole period for inmates released from prison.
Under current law, inmates who complete their full term sentence are released without parole supervision. Inmates who are released short of completing their entire sentence are still monitored by the Department of Correction through the parole process.
"I think, very clearly, if we take efforts to reintegrate people, their chance of success is going to be much better," Sali said.
But both proposals may be nonstarters; Gov. Dirk Kempthorne in January created a special commission to examine the state's criminal sentences. And Senate Judiciary Chairman Denton Darrington has vowed to block any measure that would result in lighter sentences for the state's prison population.
Still, House Judiciary Committee members say the prison crisis at least makes the proposals worth examining now, rather than waiting for Kempthorne's commission to move.
The first proposal is from Boise Republican Rep. Steve Smylie, whose plan would allow inmates who have completed education, drug abuse and other required treatments to shave four months off their sentences.
That, Smylie said, would potentially save the state as much as $4 million a year.
Another proposal, from Kuna Republican Rep. Bill Sali, would allow prisoners who have committed nonviolent crimes to automatically be paroled as long as certain conditions are met.
Smylie said his proposal is modeled after a similar plan used in Nebraska, where the prisons have fewer inmates than Idaho's more than 6,300, even though Nebraska has half a million more people than Idaho.
Republican Rep. Jim Clark of Hayden Lake objected to considering Smylie's proposal, saying the governor's commission was going to do its own examination of the issue.
But Pocatello Democratic Rep. Donna Boe pushed for legislative review right away.
"It seems to me that were we to pass this through the Legislature, it would get more attention" from the governor's commission, Boe said.
Boe succeeded in backing the introduction of Smylie's bill, complete with her own changes, giving the Parole Commission veto authority over a reduced sentence.
Sali's proposal would restrict the Parole Commission's ability to block the parole of nonviolent offenders unless the panel can demonstrate that the release of the prisoner would be a threat to society.
If the inmate has no disciplinary issues, has finished prison treatment and other required programs, he can be let go after finishing the minimum, or fixed, portion of the prison sentence. The bill would also create a six-month mandatory parole period for inmates released from prison.
Under current law, inmates who complete their full term sentence are released without parole supervision. Inmates who are released short of completing their entire sentence are still monitored by the Department of Correction through the parole process.
"I think, very clearly, if we take efforts to reintegrate people, their chance of success is going to be much better," Sali said.